Wednesday, 11 June 2008
LOCAL OPINION: Utah needs a few more good 'educrats' Print E-mail
Daily Herald   

Deon Turley

My youngest daughter graduated from sixth grade last week. As we drove away from the school for the last time, I found myself thinking about the challenges of the education community.

A recent letter to this newspaper commented on the large numbers of opposition candidates vying for a seat in the Utah Legislature. Noting that many were from the teaching profession, it warned against the election of "educrats" who want to take over the Legislature.

Certainly there is a strong showing of the education community in the field of candidates this year. I see it as a natural response to the Legislature's arrogant disregard of constituents' support of public education.

I was, however, fascinated by the term "educrat." It isn't found in the dictionary and the word itself sounds like something spat on the ground. Who would want a title like that?

If having a commitment to public education makes me an educrat, it is a label I'll gladly accept. If recognizing the need for excellence in institutions of higher education in the state and wanting to fund them sufficiently makes me an educrat, I admit to it. If efforts to provide everyone literacy training and educational opportunity would make me an educrat, sign me up.

Statistically, Utah is the youngest state in the nation. Families are large, and school-age children make up a large percentage of our population. Young people left to popular media, television and advertising, won't find training for informed citizenship. Preparation for their emergence into responsible adulthood requires a large investment.

It is well-established that education is power --not only measured in earning capacity but in ability to control one's own life. We want our children to understand how to function in an increasingly complex world. The educated citizen is more likely to tell a good idea from a bad one, a trustworthy steward from a swindler. Most families rely on public schools to help them teach their children to become independent, thoughtful individuals.

Our society also invests in the future through education. Public schools should prepare children to become productive, informed citizens. We all benefit when doctors know how to operate, when architects can design a building well, and when engineers create planes, trains, and cars that get us where we need to go in a safe manner.

The training of teachers has never been better. They are being prepared to teach a wide range of children with various individual challenges, family circumstances and cultural backgrounds. The administrators of public schools and state institutions of higher education shoulder responsibilities that are comparable to CEOs of large businesses.

The biggest difference between schools and business enterprises is that business generates its own income; public education must rely on public revenue controlled by elected officials. Our state legislators show their commitment by what they are willing to nurture, support and entrust.

Nurturing the education community means giving them manageable class sizes. The current student-to-teacher ratios in Utah are among the highest in the nation. This means our students get the lowest levels of individual attention of any group of public-school students in the country.

Supporting the education community means providing the funds necessary to do the job. That hasn't happened in our state. Public school employees in Utah are among the lowest paid in the nation. Per-pupil funding of education continues to place Utah at the bottom of the stack, relative to every other state in the nation.

Trusting the education community means allowing parents, teachers and administrators at the local level to control their budgets and curriculum. In this year's legislative session, a big part of the increased education funding went to specific state-defined programs. School officials who see the needs of the students and employees at close range are constantly shuffling budget categories to meet the requirements of earmarked funding.

The effects of this neglect take years to emerge, but they are showing up now. Scores that show preparation for post-high-school training are dropping, and measurements of technical understanding among Utah's population are showing a decline. This trend must stop. To scrimp on education is to leave the next generation unprepared for the challenges of a complex world.

We must be willing to nurture, support and trust the education community. Our Legislature could use a few more educrats who will do that.


Deon Turley is the outgoing president of the Provo Council PTA.

Article views: 697  
User Rating: / 10
PoorBest 
Discuss (2 posts)
instereo72 Jun 11 2008 17:48:24
This thread discusses the Content article: LOCAL OPINION: Utah needs a few more good 'educrats'

Educrats, what a crazy word. It makes you think of democrats, liberals, beurocrats or some other terrible kind of crats. What it really shows to me is that in Utah there are a significant number of people who don't value education. They think of it as a drain on the economy not as an investment in our community. They think of it as something that destroys values when it really passes along values. (I think if these anti-education people were in schools, they'd see that it not only passes on values important for our society but teaches many values to many students who obviously don't get them at home.) They look at schools as some vast conspiracy yet if they looked farther they'd see dedicated individuals who want to better society. They see "lack of choice" when in reality there is an abundance of choice for students and parents.

Actually when people invent words like "Educrats" they are tipping their hand in showing their hate and disgust for anything having to do with our education system, improving our communities, teachers, students, and families. So I'd say it appears obvious that we should regect those kind of people and vote for people who do care about schools and our communities and families even if they are educators, former educators, or education lovers.
#373412
LawJunkie Jun 11 2008 18:59:41
Actually, the word "educrat" simply makes me think of a combination of educator and bureaucrat. To me, this is the biggest danger of our public school system. We allow the bureaucracy to take over and protect teacher unions at the expense of our children. Then, when anybody disagrees with the approach, they are anti-education.

The United States spends more on education per pupil than any nation in the world, yet we are far behind when it comes to actually educating our students. Utah spends less per pupil and has bigger class-sizes than any state in the Nation, yet it consistently performs well on national tests. Right now I'm living in Cleveland, OH which spends a FORTUNE on education and has a 34% high school graduation rate. (that's graduation not dropout) Question: If these statements are true, why do liberals constantly return to the old mantra of raising taxes and spending more money to fix the education problem? Has this worked well in the last 50 years? Isn't it time to try a new approach?

I have nothing against teachers or former teachers wanting to run for office. But if their "solution" to the education problem is to spend more money and get more perks for unions and administrators, a few warnings should go up. Chances are they are far more interested in protecting their bureaucracy than in actually educating children. If so, I think the term educrat is quite apt.
#373453


Discuss this article on the forums. (2 posts)
CNA's or LPNs Tophams Tiny Tots
CNA/ Hospice/ Home Care Life Paths Hospice and Home Health
Utah Department of Corrections-Human Resources Healthcare Help Wanted
Utah Department of Corrections-Human Resources Medical Help Wanted
Care Giver $10.70/hr RN/LPN positions Utah State Developmental Center
Staff Nurse and Medical Assistant Full time Heritage School
Mentoring of America LLC Office/Admin Help Wanted

See All Top Jobs Post your job
PAYSON- 549 N. 750 E. Real Estate South County
Orem + Berkshire By owner Real Estate Provo/Orem
Lehi. Prestigious East side. $499,000 Real Estate North County
BRING YOUR TOYS! Summer Recreational Property

See all Top Homes List your property
Generated in 0.46168 Seconds