Friday, 15 August 2008
HERALD POLL: Time for cities to trim costs? Print E-mail
Daily Herald   

Many Utah Valley families are finding that an economic slowdown provides a great incentive to jettison extra expenses -- and cities and school districts now have that wonderful opportunity.

Unfortunately, some municipalities want to raise taxes. They ought instead to be looking at ways to trim the fat.

At 6:30 p.m. today, Woodland Hills is holding a hearing on a tax hike that would amount to $291 a year on a $350,000 home.

 

Wednesday will bring similar hearings in other cities. The tax rate increases being pondered include:

Elk Ridge, a $79 annual tax hike on a $250,000 home;

Mapleton, a $182 increase on a $350,000 home;

Saratoga Springs, a $293 rise in the levy on a $350,000 home.

Provo School District and Nebo School District have also looked at boosting taxes.

Raising taxes, however, shouldn't even be on the table for most local taxing bodies. We'd guess that during recent years when the economy boomed, local governments felt free to boost staff and take on big projects or add services.

But as a retreating tide will reveal a lot of flotsam and jetsam on the beach, the sputtering national and state economies will expose the extras, if only one takes a look.

Saratoga Springs, to its credit, trimmed a 2008-2009 budget shortfall first estimated at $3.5 million to less than half that. Among the steps: cost cutting in all departments except for public safety; trimming the tab for city celebrations; cuts or delays in road projects; wage and hiring freezes; and the elimination of 14 full-time and four part-time positions.

American Fork trimmed a proposed tax increase of 40 percent to less than 10 percent by paring a "wish list" of city projects down to just one -- repairing streets.

So it can be done. And we wouldn't be surprised if even deeper cuts could be made in those towns and others with no fatal harm.

If officials can't find anyplace to cut, they can draw on a pool of experts who can give them hints: local residents. Most of them have spent a lot of time the past few months looking over their own expenditures and looking for ways to save money.

Here's a good example of what happens with public input: Mapleton had been considering a tax increase for a library, but city leaders asked residents to weigh in. "So far, all the comments we have received have been opposed to the expenditure," Mayor Laurel Brady said in the latest city newsletter. "I don't see any way the council will vote to fund the library with such overwhelming opposition."

Today's financial realities should also spur innovation. Mapleton deserves applause for the clever move of having garbage bins collected only on one side of the street, making collections easier -- and cheaper. There must be dozens of ways each city in Utah Valley can operate with greater financial efficiency. All that would take is a determination to look at city operations in a fresh light.

A side benefit of financial jitters is an urge toward better management. For instance, in Saratoga Springs, one council member said the council had been "blindsided" by the looming fiscal crisis when told of it in May.

Why didn't the council know or suspect this earlier? The answer may be in one of those improvements: From now on, city staff will give the council monthly budget updates.

Monthly updates? In today's world, any well-run small business provides its owners with weekly or daily updates on finances. In other words, the city council in Saratoga Springs has been basically flying blind for who knows how long.

It's another good bet that many other towns across the county have fallen behind in their business practices. The silver lining could be that the current fiscal troubles could be the kick in the pants they need to develop more efficient operations.

There's one more opportunity available here -- for taxpayers. Keeping costs in line is also their responsibility. And a tax hike doesn't have to be on the agenda. If you don't want one, you better speak up.

In Alpine, the council and mayor reportedly are mulling raising their own salaries. At the moment the picture is a bit murky, what with the mayor plotting the move privately with council members. Alpine residents should demand that this process take place in the public eye.

To give another example, on Aug. 26 a proposed pay hike for Lehi City Council members and the mayor will be discussed at a public hearing. We urge Lehi residents to attend the meeting, to use the telephone, send e-mails and generally grill the panel studying this proposal -- with emphasis on explaining (if they can) how the city, not its elected officials, would profit.

These times have their troubles, but also their opportunities. Area municipalities and school districts could come out of this with more efficient operations, but only if they scorn the crutch of tax increases and instead use this time to slim down their spending -- just as families are doing.

In this time of fiscal distress, should cities and school boards raise taxes? Send your comments to This e-mail address is being protected from spam bots, you need JavaScript enabled to view it or call 344-2942. Please leave your name, hometown and phone number with your comments. E-mail comments should not exceed 100 words; voicemail comments should be no longer than 30 seconds. Anonymous and unverifiable responses will not be published. You can also comment online at our home page at heraldextra.com. The Daily Herald will publish results on Aug. 17.


Article views: 1,296  
User Rating: / 7
PoorBest 
Discuss (5 posts)
J.M. Aug 16 2008 03:45:17
This thread discusses the Content article: HERALD POLL: Time for cities to trim costs?

I think this question is somewhat misleading. Obviously everyone is opposed to increasing taxes, especially right now. The question should be what services are you willing to cut in order to decrease taxes. With every cut, service levels will drop in one way or another. This article is also misleading because it only takes into account the increase that people are being asked to pay. The Daily Herald should do a side by side comparison of every city in Utah County and compare the actual costs of living in each city. This should include both the property taxes and utilities. Because some cities are raising taxes now doesn't mean that they will be higher than other cities (in fact some listed in the article are currently taxed on the low end relative to other cities). The Daily Herald should be highlighting those cities that are higher taxed cities, even if they are not proposing increases now.
#387647
unaffiliated_person Aug 16 2008 18:43:55
J.M. wrote:
This thread discusses the Content article: HERALD POLL: Time for cities to trim costs?

I think this question is somewhat misleading. Obviously everyone is opposed to increasing taxes, especially right now. The question should be what services are you willing to cut in order to decrease taxes. With every cut, service levels will drop in one way or another. This article is also misleading because it only takes into account the increase that people are being asked to pay. The Daily Herald should do a side by side comparison of every city in Utah County and compare the actual costs of living in each city. This should include both the property taxes and utilities. Because some cities are raising taxes now doesn't mean that they will be higher than other cities (in fact some listed in the article are currently taxed on the low end relative to other cities). The Daily Herald should be highlighting those cities that are higher taxed cities, even if they are not proposing increases now.


Best option is for people to look at their city's budget. It is not hidden, so they can see where the money is going.
#387698
joeschmoe Aug 18 2008 20:00:12
Who writes these poll questions?


"In this time of fiscal distress, should cities and school boards raise taxes?"


Hmmmmm. I wonder what the poll writer wants the answer to be?

I literally laughed out loud when I read that question.
#387900

Web Geek
Aug 19 2008 22:57:18
joeschmoe wrote:
Who writes these poll questions?


"In this time of fiscal distress, should cities and school boards raise taxes?"


Hmmmmm. I wonder what the poll writer wants the answer to be?

I literally laughed out loud when I read that question.


My thoughts exactly. Someone needs to take a class in polling & surveys.
#388143

Web Geek
Aug 19 2008 22:57:22
#388144


Discuss this article on the forums. (5 posts)
Generated in 0.16232 Seconds