×
×
homepage logo

BYU 1-on-1: Cougar football looking for first victory against Kansas

By Darnell Dickson and Brandon C. Gurney - Daily Herald | Nov 18, 2026

Courtesy BYU Photo

BYU's Tommy Prassass (22) intercepts a pass against Baylor in a college football game at LaVell Edwards Stadium on Saturday, Nov. 14, 2026.

Daily Herald sports writers Darnell Dickson and Brandon Gurney debate and pontificate on the hot BYU sports topics of the week.

1. What do you think about BYU football staying at No. 10 in the College Football Playoff rankings this week?

DICKSON: It was a pleasant surprise that the CFP committee wasn’t overwhelmed by the shiny lights of Wake Forest’s blowout of SMU or Texas Tech’s blowout of Oklahoma State to move them ahead of BYU. The Cougars continue to ride the wave of the win against Notre Dame despite going 2-2 since beating the Irish. It’s also ironic that the Red Raiders might miss the playoffs even if they make the Big 12 Championship Game. It just shows how screwy the current playoff system is and as much as I think 24 teams is too many at least we’ll be clear of this nonsense. As for BYU. beating Kansas and Cincinnati to end the season seems to be the path to the playoffs. None of that is a given considering the way the Cougars have played in the past month.

GURNEY: It solidifies BYU standing and is absolutely a positive with regards to its path in garnering an at-large bid. The big fear for all involved was that Wake Forest’s demolition of SMU on the road would work for the committee to vault the Demon Deacons over the Cougars in the rankings. But although it was a very impressive win, it wasn’t enough for the committee, and it very much shouldn’t be when considering how much weaker the ACC Conference is than the Big 12 by most metrics.

So BYU’s path is relatively clear, at this point in that you have to hope that neither Wake Forest or Texas Tech win their respective conference championship games. If both do as much, then it could spell trouble for the Cougars, but if either of them take a loss, then the Cougars should be in. Of course none of this matters if BYU can’t win its two remaining games in the regular season.

2. The Cougars have yet to score more than 28 points (in regulation) of any Big 12 game this season. Concerned?

GURNEY: I think it’s a concern, but probably not as big of one as a lot of fans are assigning. It’s how Kalani Sitake manages games, and with BYU set to return LJ Martin to full action, look for the offense to continue to milk the clock while relying on the defense to get things done on its end. It’s called complementary football, and Sitake is big on it, and although the results can produce relatively unspectacular win totals, it’s hard to argue with Sitake’s success in producing win totals.

Harold Mitchell, Special to the Herald

BYU's Brooks Bahr goes in for a layup against Montana State in a men's college basketball game at the Marriott Center on Thursday, Nov. 12, 2026.

So again, it would be a good thing, and I don’t think Sitake would be in any way opposed to his offense scoring more than 30 points (duh), but I do not believe it’s nearly as important than a lot of fans and pundits alike are asserting.

DICKSON: Gurney is right about the way Kalani Sitake and his coaches manage games. In reality, it’s kind of how the NFL works. In that league, it doesn’t matter if you win by 3 or 33, the ‘W’ is the only thing that matters. We all know college football doesn’t work the same way and it’s easy for voters to get distracted by teams running up the score and the bias toward teams from the Big Ten and the SEC. Still, Sitake seems content to simply worry about winning and let the other stuff take care of itself. So far it hasn’t resulted in a CFP invite, but he believes it will someday. Do you?

I think the offense is capable of scoring more than 30 points. The Cougars would have last week without a couple of questionable penalties. How important is it? I suppose not that important as long as BYU scores more than their opponent.

3. What is the key to winning at Kansas on Saturday?

DICKSON: Football is about one-on-one matchups and how many you can win, and that leads to my key point. Execution is the way to victory, on both sides of the ball. Everyone doing their job more consistently that your opponent. Every game plan is set up to take advantage of where you have the edge. The more times all 11 guys can do their jobs, the greater your chances of winning. BYU’s offensive and defensive coordinators have taken some heat at various times this season but they don’t block or tackle anybody. The execution on the field has to be the key to getting a win on Saturday.

GURNEY: The big key is for BYU’s running backs to run for over 100 yards. If Bear Bachmeier elects to help with that total, then fine, but producing a viable rushing attack, especially on the road, has been severely lacking since Martin went down versus TCU and you have to look no further than last week’s win over Baylor to understand just how big of a difference Martin makes. With his participation versus the Bears in the first half BYU ran for 150 yards on 30 carries. With Martin sitting out all of the second half that run total was just 39 yards on 17 total carries.

Courtesy BYU Athletics

BYU's Emma Neff (9) kicks the ball against Colorado at the Big 12 Women's Soccer Tournament in Mansfield, Texas, on Wednesday, Nov. 11, 2026.

So yeah, having Martin back is huge, and indications are that he may finally be ready to take on a full load, which should help tremendously in defeating a solid Kansas team on the road.

4. What do you think of BYU’s chances of winning the Southwest Maui Invitational next week, something the Cougars have never done?

GURNEY: I like the chances quite a bit, as crazy as that is to say. The Cougars should be favored in every game that doesn’t include Arizona, and so far this season the team has looked ahead of the curve with regards to execution, much more than they did throughout most of last season, and I expect that to pay dividends in Maui. Also, presenting a top point guard to manage thing is a big thing in any tournament, and given that Rob Wright will be the best point guard out there in Maui, it certainly plays to BYU’s advantage. So yeah, I’m riding the wave of momentum the Cougars have built on the early season to the point where I believe winning the Maui Invitational is a strong possibility.

DICKSON: I remember when the Maui Invitational was the biggest non-conference tournament on the planet. It was “must-see-TV” during Thanksgiving week. I even covered it once (in 2014) and was amazed at how small the arena was for such a big tournament. Now there are dozens of ESPN-owned MTE’s (multi-team events) that dilute the product. The field in Maui looks like an interesting path to playing a non-league Big 12 final against Arizona, which, by the way, just found out that Clemson fifth-year transfer RJ Godfrey is eligible thanks to (surprise!) a court decision. The already loaded Wildcats would be a difficult opponent in the final but a good chance for the Cougars to test themselves.

5. The BYU women’s soccer team hosts Weber State in the first round of the NCAA Tournament on Friday. How far do you think the Cougars can go in Jennifer Rockwood’s final season as head coach?

DICKSON: Things didn’t look very good back in September when BYU got blown out at Utah State 4-0. They’d lost leading scorer Ellie Walbruch to a knee injury and were really having trouble scoring. The Cougars have really made the most of their season despite only scoring more than three goals five times all season. The defense is solid, the goalkeeping is really good and this team is committed to making Rockwood’s final season special. The NCAA has set up a possible second-round meeting against the Aggies, and that should be fun. Projecting forward, BYU would have to beat Notre Dame in South Bend to reach the Sweet 16, which is a huge obstacle. But soccer is a crazy sport where one play can decide the game, so who knows?

GURNEY: I think a Final Four berth is certainly a possibility, although I’m going to predict an Elite 8 finish for a Cougar team that has impressed quite a bit in the wake of the season-ending injury to start Ellie Walbruch. Give me the goalkeeper play of Chelsea Peterson, who has been outstanding, and that boosts my optimism for this team even more. The team is riding high after winning both the regular season and tournament Big 12 Conference crowns, and that momentum should carry into the NCAA tournament with the team poised to send Rockwood off with another deep run.

Starting at $4.32/week.

Subscribe Today