Inside Darnell’s Head: Take a breath, Cougar fans, your boys got a win
- BYU running back LJ Martin (left) takes a handoff from Bear Bachmeier against Kansas in a Big 12 football game at Lawrence, Kan., on Saturday, November 21, 2026.
- Darnell Dickson, Daily Herald

Courtesy BYU Photo
BYU running back LJ Martin (left) takes a handoff from Bear Bachmeier against Kansas in a Big 12 football game at Lawrence, Kan., on Saturday, November 21, 2026.
Here’s what’s going on inside Darnell’s head after BYU’s wild three-overtime win against Kansas.
Well, actually, not immediately after. I could have started this column sooner but I wanted to marinate on it a bit. I wanted to read what others thought of the game. I wanted to scroll through ‘X’ and listen to the talking heads on TV.
Why? Because my knee-jerk reaction is usually a lot harsher. I don’t want to just blast the Cougars with emotion.
Isn’t that kind of me?
I just want to say, BYU fans, I feel you. There is nothing more frustrating in the current state of college football than having to argue that your team is good enough for the playoffs. The Cougars needed a comfortable win against Kansas on Saturday to shut down the naysayers. Instead, we got a triple overtime, target-heart-rate finish that was equal parts exciting and frustrating.

Darnell Dickson, Daily Herald
Yes, BYU is an imperfect team. They zig when they should zag, they miss tackles on defense and they don’t execute consistently on offense.
Which makes them like just about every other team in college football (we’re ignoring you, Utah. Everything you do is perfect).
If the Cougars beat Cincinnati next week — convincingly or otherwise — do they belong in the CFP? If I say, “yes” will I get shouted down on social media by Wake Forest fans?
Probably. To both questions.
Now it’s time for Perfectly Rational Overreactions (PROs).
PRO No. 1: Bear Bachmeier has regained his mojo.
Don’t get me wrong, Bachmeier is an excellent quarterback. I don’t feel like he’s made a big leap from his freshman season like we were promised by coaches during fall camp, but he’s still a gamer. The beginning of the Kansas game didn’t go well but he got the Cougars to the finish line and made a very difficult throw under pressure for the game-winning two-point conversion. He’s got his security blanket back in LJ Martin and his teammates still believe in him. The Cougars are riding with Bear (that doesn’t make animal sense, but go with me here) and there’s no reason why you shouldn’t.
PRO No. 2: Everybody will be healthy for the Cincinnati game and the Cougars will roll.
Kalani Sitake certainly thinks so, based on his post-game comments. He went on a tangent about getting guys like Evan Johnson, Andrew Gentry and Isaiah Glasker back this week and that BYU will play its best football now. The only question is “will it be enough?” There’s been a lot of chaos in college football and the Cougars are right in the middle of it. A healthy BYU team might be the team we thought they were when the season started. Let’s hope they get a chance to prove it on the biggest stage.
PRO No. 3: Aaron Roderick is the right man for the job as offensive coordinator.
I only say that because it sure seems as if many of you are convinced he’s not. I get it. Not everything he does makes sense to you and second-guessing the OC is a God-given right for football fans. I’d like to think that Roderick is playing 3D chess and we’re all playing checkers, that even his questionable calls are setting up something even better later on, but who really knows? It’s important to remember that every BYU opponent has a defensive coordinator who is very good at his job and spends the whole week preparing to counter every move that Roderick makes. Sometimes the other guy wins. The end result over the past three seasons (32-6) means Roderick gets the best of the other guy more often than not.
And finally, PRO No. 4: BYU is definitely a College Football Playoff team.
On Tuesday we’ll find out what the College Football Playoff committee thinks of BYU. We’ll find out if the Notre Dame win still holds up (it should) or if the suits are more impressed with Wake Forest pounding untalented opponents into the turf. I’ve seen some projections that have the Cougars in the CFP if they win on Saturday against Cincinnati. If only it were that simple.
Next season, 24 teams make the playoffs and we probably won’t be having this discussion. We’ll be talking about how the CFP is screwing BYU’s seeding instead. Won’t that be nice?
Who Carried the Boats and the Logs?
Did anybody make two bigger plays than wide receiver Jo Jo Phillips? He had two catches for 36 yards in the box score but one of those snags was for a key fourth-down conversion that set up BYU’s first touchdown. His catch for the game-winning two-point conversion was against double coverage. Phillips is supremely talented and deserves more targets.
No flags
There wasn’t a single penalty called in the BYU-Kansas game, a stunning development if you’ve ever watched a college football game on any given Saturday. According to Google, the last time that happened was in a 2022 matchup between Iowa and Minnesota. Before that, it was Army-Navy in 1986. Most certainly, it’s never happened in a triple overtime game.
I don’t know whether to congratulate the teams for playing such a clean game or force the officials to give back some of their salary.
The game wasn’t without controversy, though. Apparently, determining whether a player made a “football move” in the completion of a catch is beyond the ability of the replay booth.
Get off my lawn
I see that there are BYU fans angry that Sitake opted to set up for the game-winning field goal in the final seconds instead of running a few more plays. Are you serious? I feel like I’m taking crazy pills here. You play to win the game. The Cougars ran the four-minute offense to perfection and set up Matthias Dunn for a chip shot field goal to win it with no opportunity for Kansas to counter. He shanks the kick into Nebraska and that’s Sitake’s fault? I know most of you grew up playing EA Sports College Football and that game has a reset button if you make a bad choice. That’s not how college football works. There are real consequences to consider and setting up for the field goal was completely the right move.
Now go play GTA6 and try to justify it to your bishop.
Paradise on the court
Kevin Young and the Cougars are in the islands this week for the Southwest Maui Invitational. BYU passed a pretty big test to open the season against Ohio State and has spent the past month beating up on teams they are supposed to beat. Now, the talent level goes up and we’ll see what we’ll see against better competition. I’ll be paying special attention to the defensive side. That’s a place where the Cougars have the most room to grow. Anybody up for a day-before-Thanksgiving matchup with Arizona in the championship game?
That’s all for now, but for this: It might be difficult for BYU fans to appreciate the triple OT win against Kansas, or even the Cougars’ women’s soccer team holding off underdog Weber State in the first round of the NCAA Tournament by scoring in the final ten seconds.
You’re much better off realizing that every win is precious and college sports are unpredictable.
Have a great week and be safe cooking that turkey.



